Sign up for our mailing list:

Complaint Upheld

April 19th, 2001

Determination 128: Big Lake Residents and Zimmerman Citizens for Low Cost Metro Access v. West Sherburne Tribune

Participants included the spokesman for the complainants, Larry Miller, a manufacturing quality manager from Big Lake, and Bruce Gordon, director of communications for the Department of Commerce (DOC), as a witness for the complainants. Gary Meyer, editor and publisher of The West Sherburne Tribune, submitted a written response to the complaint, but did not attend the hearing. The hearing took place at the Ramsey County Library in Roseville.

More »

January 1st, 2001

Determination 129: Winona County Board of Commissioners v. Winona Post

The Winona Post ran an editorial critical of the practices of the Winona County Board of Commissioners following a committee of the board meeting on January 9, 2001. After reading an incorrect report in the Winona Daily News that said the board had decided to buy a former school building in an effort to recover lost office space after a courthouse flood, the Post’s editor called the board and obtained a denial of the report. The editor concluded that if such a decision had been made, it would have to have been at an illegal meeting.

More »

October 18th, 2000

Determination 127: Dr. Phillip Sallberg v. Roseau Times-Region

Participants included the complainant, Dr. Philip Sallberg, a dentist who lives in the Klema Addition, and Jodi Driscoll, the publisher/editor of the Roseau Times-Region. The hearing took place via video-conference, with the complainant, respondent and News Council executive director at the Roseau courthouse and Council members meeting at Piek Hall at the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis campus. This was the Council’s first video conference. 

More »

October 26th, 1999

Determination 125: Roy Carlson v. Savage Pacer

Participants included the complainant, candidate Roy Carlson, and his campaign adviser, Doug Friedline, and responding for the Savage Pacer, Laurie Hartmann, publisher, and Nancy Huddleston, editor.

More »

April 19th, 1999

Determination 122: Nancy Barsness v. Morris Sun/Tribune

Participants included the complainant, Nancy Barsness and editor/general manager of the Morris Sun/Tribune, Jim Morrison.

More »

December 10th, 1998

Determination 121: MN DNR v. KSTP-TV

Participants for the DNR included Rod Sando, Commissioner; Ron Nargang, Deputy Commissioner; Marcy Dowse, communications manager, and Scott Pengelly, information officer. KSTP declined to participate in the hearing, but forwarded to the Council a copy of its response to the DNR.

More »

June 15th, 1998

Determination 119: Rice County Attorney Jeffrey Thompson and the Hanlon Family v. Faribault Daily News

Attending the hearing were the complainants, Jeffrey Thompson, Rice County Attorney and Assistant County Attorney Noah Cashman, and the Hanlon Family: Donna (mother), Casey, Kelly, and Katie (children) and the children’s uncle, Dan Hanlon. Representing the Faribault Daily News were Lisa Schwarz, managing editor, and David Balcom, publisher.

More »

April 16th, 1998

Determination 118: Patrick Michaels, Robert Balling v. Star Tribune

 

NOTE: The Minnesota News Council hears complaints about journalistic ethics. The Council DID NOT make a ruling on the accuracy or integrity of the science of the two climatologists. That question is beyond the purvue of the Council.

Attending the hearing were the complainants, Dr. Patrick Michaels, Professor of Environmental Sciences at the University of Virginia, and Dr. Robert Balling, Director, Office of Climatology, Arizona State University. Respondents for the Star Tribune were Susan Albright, Editorial Page editor; Jim Lenfestey, formerly employed at the Star Tribune and writer of the editorial in question; Kate Stanley, current global warming editorial writer; and Eric Ringham, Commentary Page editor.

More »

June 12th, 1997

Determination 116: Police Lt. Mike Sauro v. Star Tribune

Attending the hearing was the complainant, Minneapolis Police Lieutenant Mike Sauro. The Star Tribune declined to attend, saying it did not contest the validity of the complaint.

More »

June 12th, 1997

Determination 115: Patty & Randy Brandt v. WCCO-TV

Attending the hearing were the complainants, Patty and Randy Brandt, dairy farmers from Marshall, MN. WCCO-TV declined to attend.

More »