Sign up for our mailing list:

Complaint Denied

August 22nd, 2008

News Council Denies Two Complaints Against the Morrison County Record

The Minnesota News Council denied two complaints against the Morrison County Record by state legislator Al Doty (DFL-Royalton).

Rep. Doty complained to the News Council after the paper published a March 2 story, “Local GOP objects to Doty’s support of gas tax hike.” The Record’s editor and general manager, Tom West, approached Doty for comment “on the gas tax,” but did not tell him it would be used in a news story about Doty’s support of a transportation bill. In an effort to balance a press release issued by Republican leaders in the district, West rewrote the press release to include comments from Doty and the county engineer, as well as additional background information. More »

February 22nd, 2008

Determination 153: Gary Glass v. Duluth Budgeteer News

The Minnesota News Council voted Thursday to deny three complaints against the Duluth Budgeteer News, affirming the paper’s decision to run a Nov. 4, 2007 opinion column critical of Duluth School Board candidate Gary Glass.

More »

February 15th, 2007

Determination 148: Joselyn Murphy & Tom Bruels v. Ely Echo

A complaint against the Ely Echo by two Ely school officials over a Halloween party photo was denied by the Minnesota News Council.

More »

December 14th, 2006

Determination 146: John Kysylyczyn v. Star Tribune

A complaint against the Star Tribune by the former mayor of Roseville, John Kysylyczyn, was denied today by the Minnesota News Council.  The vote was 11-to-0 with one abstention. Kysylyczyn, mayor of Roseville from 2000 to 2003, said that the Star Tribune unfairly editorialized in a July 23, 2006 news story when it used the word “antics” to characterize his administration. 

More »

January 3rd, 2005

Determination 141: Todd Peterson v. Roseau Times-Region

A complaint against the Roseau Times-Region newspaper by a city official was denied by the Minnesota News Council. The vote was 8 to 4 with one abstention.

More »

January 2nd, 2005

Determination 140: Wes Mader, Mike Gundlach, and Jim Ericson v. Prior Lake American

The News Council denied three complaints by Prior Lake’s former mayor and two city council colleagues against the Prior Lake American newspaper.

More »

January 1st, 2003

Determination 136: Rep. Arlon Lindner v. Star Tribune

The Minnesota News Council voted to deny complaints by Rep. Arlon Lindner (R-Corcoran) that the Star Tribune and the Associated Press had unfairly covered the controversy about his bill to remove sexual orientation as a protected class under the state’s human rights act.

More »

April 22nd, 2002

Determination 133: Minnesota Department of Transportation v. Star Tribune

On March 15, 2002, the Star Tribune published a news story about Department of Administration officials who questioned MnDOT’s legal and ethical behavior in awarding contracts for work on the intersection of Hwys. 55 and 62, associated with the light-rail project. An Administration official, Kent Allin, was quoted as saying, “The culture of MnDOT is to act the bully, throw one’s weight around, villainize anybody who stands in your way and not worry about wasting tax dollars.”

More »

August 16th, 2001

Determination 130: Ely City Council v. Ely Echo

The Ely City Council held a closed meeting in April to discuss its ongoing negotiations with the EPA over violations for which city was being fined. The City Council closed the meeting citing the need for a discussion of potential litigation strategy, currently an exception under Minnesota’s open meeting law. The City Council said it was protecting the concerns of the citizens by keeping the discussion of strategy confidential. The Ely Echo, one of the two newspaper’s in town, published an account of the meeting in the following week’s paper. The paper declined to respond to the city’s inquiry about the source of the article. The paper also said it was protecting the taxpayers’ interests by keeping them informed about the actions of the City Council.

More »

December 9th, 1999

Determination 126: St. Therese Home v. WCCO-TV

Participants included the complainant, Dave Bredenberg, administrator of St. Therese Nursing Home, and Jim Williams, Director of Communication for the Minnesota Health & Housing Alliance. WCCO-TV chose not to attend the hearing, but sent a written response to the complaint. 

More »